Tar and Chip vs. Asphalt Driveway: Which Fits Your Property?

Is tar and chip or asphalt the better driveway? It depends on the property. Tar and chip costs less up front, has a rough, stone surface with good traction, and suits long rural driveways where a country look fits. Hot-mix asphalt gives you a smooth, uniform surface that is easier to shovel and plow, holds up better to tight turning and suits most suburban homes. Both last only as long as the base underneath them.

We pave both around the Lehigh Valley. Long lanes up in the northern part of Lehigh County, around Slatington, Schnecksville and New Tripoli, are where tar and chip makes the most sense. In neighborhoods in Allentown, Emmaus or Macungie, most homeowners end up with asphalt.

What tar and chip actually is

Tar and chip, also called chip seal, is built in layers on top of a compacted stone base. Hot liquid asphalt is sprayed over the base, then a layer of crushed stone is spread on top and rolled into it. As the binder cools, it locks the stone in place. Some driveways get a second layer for a thicker surface.

The result looks like a stone driveway that does not move under your tires. The color comes from the stone, so you can get a lighter or warmer look than the black of fresh asphalt. The same treatment is used on roads, and the Federal Highway Administration’s chip seal checklist covers how it is applied on public pavement.

What asphalt gives you

An asphalt driveway is hot-mix asphalt placed over a prepared base and compacted with a roller. The surface is smooth and dense. That matters if you have kids on bikes, a basketball hoop or a car that gets washed in the driveway. It also matters in winter, because a shovel or plow blade slides over asphalt without catching the way it can on a stone surface.

Asphalt is also easier to maintain in a predictable way. Cracks can be filled, and the surface can be sealcoated every few years to protect it. Our post on how often to sealcoat a driveway covers that schedule.

How they compare

  • Up-front cost. Tar and chip is usually the less expensive option for the same area, which is a big reason it is popular on long driveways.
  • Look. Tar and chip has a rustic, stone finish. Asphalt is smooth and black, then fades to grey over time.
  • Traction. The stone surface of tar and chip grips well, which helps on sloped lanes.
  • Snow removal. Asphalt is easier. Plow blades can scrape stone loose from a tar and chip surface, so a plow with the blade set slightly high or shoes on the blade is a good idea.
  • Turning and parking. Power steering turns on a parked car can scuff tar and chip and pull stone loose. Asphalt handles that better.
  • Maintenance. Asphalt gets crack filling and sealcoating. Tar and chip is usually refreshed with a new layer of binder and stone when it wears.

The base decides either way

Neither surface will last on a weak base or a driveway that holds water. Before we quote either option, we look at how the driveway drains, how soft the ground is and whether the existing stone can be reused or needs to be rebuilt. If water sheets across the driveway or sits at the bottom of a slope, that gets fixed first. Our drainage and utilities work is often part of the job on rural lanes.

Can you put tar and chip over an old driveway?

Often, yes. Tar and chip can go over a sound gravel driveway that has been graded and compacted, and chip seal is also used over existing pavement that is worn but structurally sound. If the old surface is breaking up or the base has failed, it needs to be repaired or rebuilt first. Putting a new surface over a bad base just hides the problem for a season.

Which one fits your property

If you have a long driveway, a rural setting and want to keep the cost per foot down, tar and chip is worth a look. If you want a smooth surface that is easy to clear in winter and you do a lot of turning and parking, asphalt is usually the better fit. If you are still weighing a gravel driveway too, our gravel vs. asphalt comparison covers that side.

Legacy Paving PA installs tar and chip and asphalt driveways throughout the Lehigh Valley. We will walk the driveway with you, look at the base and drainage and tell you which surface makes sense. Call or text (610) 751-0998, or send us a message to set up an estimate.